Reusing newspapers to protect fruits and using bamboo branches as the trellising (Mr. Tim Sophea)

Bitter gourd cultivation using recycled newspapers to protect fruits (Cambodia)

Bitter gourd cultivation

Description

The use of old newspapers to wrap up bitter gourd, so as to prevent the fruit from being damaged by insects, and to protect them from direct sunlight and contact with pesticides. This agricultural approach only uses animal manure, fish heads and urea (46-0-0) as fertilizer to improve the soil’s quality.

Bitter gourd is a crop that can be supported by trellises and it is possible to plant it throughout the year. However it is not recommended to grow it in areas with strong winds because then it takes longer to grow. Bitter gourd requires more fertile soil than other varieties in the Cucurbitaceae family. It needs to be well-saturated or loamy soil with a pH of 6 to 6.8. The most suitable land can be found along river banks, streams, and lakes with high silt content. Bitter gourds are susceptible to be damaged by pests and diseases. In order to protect the fruit from pests, plastic, paper or other materials are wrapped around the fruit. Additionally, the crop needs nets for climbing, which can be quite expensive (Agritoday, 2016).

In this case study the farmer plants bitter gourds by using bamboo sticks to construct the trellis for plant climbing. And he wraps up the fruits with old newspapers. This growing technique is less expensive than using nets for plant climbing and medium A4 sized brown paper envelopes to protect the fruit. The bamboo sticks can be used for two years, and during this period the farmer is able to make use of them three to four times a year. The newspapers that have been bought to protect the fruit can be used two or three times, so as not only to reduce the cost but also to reduce the environmental impact. Covering the fruit with newspapers is better than using plastic bags or pages from books, because plastic bags can easily become too hot, and pages are particularly vulnerable to rain or water. The main purpose of wrapping up the bitter gourd with newspapers is to protect them from insects, especially the fruit fly. However it also protects them from the heat of the sun makes the fruit whiter, and acts as a protection against pesticides as this would otherwise be directly sprayed onto the fruit. Insecticides normally last an average of 7 to 10 days and plants will then have to be sprayed again to prevent the return of the insects. Farmers are able to harvest the bitter gourd about 15 days after pinned with newspaper.

As the area is flooded by the Mekong River during the months of August - October, it is not possible to plant bitter gourd in the rainy season. After the water has receded the soil should be ploughed and dried by the sun for 15 days. After this the soil should be plowed again, and then the field needs to be harrowed evenly and the soil left to dry for three more days. Fertilizers should not be added whilst ploughing. Planting is done by firstly using a hoe to scratch a central trench in the field. Further parallel lines to this trench should be 1.2 meters apart and the bitter gourd seeds should then be planted along the lines, at 40 centimeter intervals. Once the seeds are in the ground manure, cow or buffalo compost should be applied over the top and then watered. Before growing, it should be soaked for 2 hours and then covered with cloth. Afterwards they should be left to soak in a steady flow of water for 4 to 5 days until the shoots begin to grow. After when the developing bitter melon is 15 days old a bamboo pole with bamboo sticks of about 1.7 meters height and 10 cm from the plants has to be placed. A further 15 days after having put up the poles, the soil should be loosen up again and then the fish head fertilizer mixed with a little bit of UREA is applied. The fertilizer should be spread about 30 to 40 cm from plants, or it can be added between the bitter gourd clumps, which can also be combined with manure and UREA. Watering should be done twice a day, once in the morning and once in the evening. The irrigation system involves pumping water from a nearby lake. Even though pesticides are used regularly, if paper is not used to protect the fruits, they can still be affected by pests. Once affected the fruit falls down, becomes stunted, grows into irregular shapes, the color becomes dull. In case the fruit were directly affected by the poison it could be harmful to people’s health. Any combination of these physical symptoms can be identified very easily and monitored by the farmers themselves. Since the use of this technique the farmer’s income has increased because they are able to grow a product of good quality and high output.

Location

Location: Floodplain which is flooded from August until September, Preaek Roka village, Saob commune, Preaek Prasap district, Kratie province, Cambodia

No. of Technology sites analysed: single site

Geo-reference of selected sites
  • 106.01298, 12.45532

Spread of the Technology: evenly spread over an area (0.0021 km²)

In a permanently protected area?:

Date of implementation: 10-50 years ago

Type of introduction
Using newspaper to wrap up the bitter gurd fruits (Mr. Tim Sophea)
Farmer is wrapping up fruits with old newspaper (Mr. Tim Sophea)

Classification of the Technology

Main purpose
  • improve production
  • reduce, prevent, restore land degradation
  • conserve ecosystem
  • protect a watershed/ downstream areas – in combination with other Technologies
  • preserve/ improve biodiversity
  • reduce risk of disasters
  • adapt to climate change/ extremes and its impacts
  • mitigate climate change and its impacts
  • create beneficial economic impact
  • create beneficial social impact
  • Protecting fruit from insects
Land use

  • Cropland
    • Annual cropping: vegetables - melon, pumpkin, squash or gourd. Cropping system: Vegetables - wheat/barley/oat/upland rice
    Number of growing seasons per year: 2
Water supply
  • rainfed
  • mixed rainfed-irrigated
  • full irrigation

Purpose related to land degradation
  • prevent land degradation
  • reduce land degradation
  • restore/ rehabilitate severely degraded land
  • adapt to land degradation
  • not applicable
Degradation addressed
  • chemical soil deterioration - Cn: fertility decline and reduced organic matter content (not caused by erosion)
  • biological degradation - Bc: reduction of vegetation cover, Bl: loss of soil life
SLM group
  • integrated soil fertility management
  • integrated pest and disease management (incl. organic agriculture)
SLM measures
  • agronomic measures - A1: Vegetation/ soil cover, A2: Organic matter/ soil fertility
  • other measures

Technical drawing

Technical specifications
The size of the plot of land is 2100 square meters (a width of 30 meters x a length of 70 meters) containing 25 rows, which are about 70 meters in length and 1.2 meters apart from each other. Along each row there is a distance of 40 cm between each plant and the trellises have a height of 1.70 meters. Then the fruit have been wrapped with newspaper to protected from sunlight, insects and pesticide applied, and also to keep the fruit white.
Author: Dr. So Than and Mr. Khuon Sophal

Establishment and maintenance: activities, inputs and costs

Calculation of inputs and costs
  • Costs are calculated: per Technology area (size and area unit: 2100 square meters)
  • Currency used for cost calculation: Riel
  • Exchange rate (to USD): 1 USD = 4000.0 Riel
  • Average wage cost of hired labour per day: 20000 Riel
Most important factors affecting the costs
High costs for pumping machine, fish head fertilizer and compost.
Establishment activities
  1. First plow is keeping 15 days (Timing/ frequency: December)
  2. Second plow is keeping 3 days (Timing/ frequency: December)
  3. Nursery and propagation (Timing/ frequency: December)
  4. Draw the line and planting (Timing/ frequency: January)
  5. Watering (Timing/ frequency: January)
  6. Collection of bamboo branches (Timing/ frequency: November)
  7. Prepare fish head fertilizer, compost, and urea (46-0-0) (Timing/ frequency: August or September)
  8. Prepare newspaper for wrap up fruits (Timing/ frequency: December)
  9. Buying the tools such as spade, knife, large basket, and water pumping machine. (Timing/ frequency: November)
  10. Self keeping seeds (Timing/ frequency: March)
Establishment inputs and costs (per 2100 square meters)
Specify input Unit Quantity Costs per Unit (Riel) Total costs per input (Riel) % of costs borne by land users
Labour
Nursery and watering peson-day 3.5 20000.0 70000.0 100.0
Plowing 2 times peson-day 3.75 20000.0 75000.0 100.0
Draw the line and planting peson-day 8.0 20000.0 160000.0 100.0
Equipment
Pumping machine piece 1.0 1600000.0 1600000.0 100.0
Spade piece 2.0 20000.0 40000.0 100.0
Knife piece 2.0 20000.0 40000.0 100.0
Large basket pair 1.0 5000.0 5000.0 100.0
Plant material
Seeds seed 3000.0 60.0 180000.0 100.0
Fertilizers and biocides
Fish head fertilizer, compost and urea kg 200.0 2500.0 500000.0 100.0
Construction material
Bamboo branches piece 100.0 5000.0 500000.0 100.0
Other
Newspaper kg 40.0 1000.0 40000.0 100.0
Spraying tank piece 1.0 80000.0 80000.0 100.0
Total costs for establishment of the Technology 3'290'000.0
Total costs for establishment of the Technology in USD 822.5
Maintenance activities
  1. Making soil soft and adding fertilizer (Timing/ frequency: after the plants are 15 days old)
  2. Adding more soil at bottom of plants, putting fertilizer and trellising (Timing/ frequency: After making the soil soft during 15 days)
  3. Watering (Timing/ frequency: Everyday (morning and evening))
  4. Checking for insects (Timing/ frequency: Everyday)
  5. Wrap up fruits with newspaper (Timing/ frequency: When fruits are provided)
  6. Spraying pesticide to prevent insects (Timing/ frequency: When insects are appeared)
  7. Spraying fish head fertilizer, animals manure, and urea (Timing/ frequency: 3 times for life cycle)
Maintenance inputs and costs (per 2100 square meters)
Specify input Unit Quantity Costs per Unit (Riel) Total costs per input (Riel) % of costs borne by land users
Labour
Making the soil to be soft, adding more soil at bottom of plants, and trellising person-day 8.0 20000.0 160000.0 100.0
Fertilizers and biocides
Urea (46-0-0)) kg 6.0 2500.0 15000.0 100.0
Pesticide bottle 2.0 15000.0 30000.0 100.0
Fish head kg 50.0 600.0 30000.0 100.0
Other
Gasoline to pumping for irrigation (3 months) liter 45.0 3200.0 144000.0 100.0
Total costs for maintenance of the Technology 379'000.0
Total costs for maintenance of the Technology in USD 94.75

Natural environment

Average annual rainfall
  • < 250 mm
  • 251-500 mm
  • 501-750 mm
  • 751-1,000 mm
  • 1,001-1,500 mm
  • 1,501-2,000 mm
  • 2,001-3,000 mm
  • 3,001-4,000 mm
  • > 4,000 mm
Agro-climatic zone
  • humid
  • sub-humid
  • semi-arid
  • arid
Specifications on climate
Average annual rainfall in mm: 1138.2
The average annual rainfall in 2015 is 1138.2 mm, in 2014 is 1696.5 mm in 2013 is 1661.8 mm.
Name of the meteorological station: Ministry of Water Resources and Meteorology (2015)
The weather is hot and humid that contain two seasons, dry and rainy season, and last year the weather was warmer than every year.
Slope
  • flat (0-2%)
  • gentle (3-5%)
  • moderate (6-10%)
  • rolling (11-15%)
  • hilly (16-30%)
  • steep (31-60%)
  • very steep (>60%)
Landforms
  • plateau/plains
  • ridges
  • mountain slopes
  • hill slopes
  • footslopes
  • valley floors
Altitude
  • 0-100 m a.s.l.
  • 101-500 m a.s.l.
  • 501-1,000 m a.s.l.
  • 1,001-1,500 m a.s.l.
  • 1,501-2,000 m a.s.l.
  • 2,001-2,500 m a.s.l.
  • 2,501-3,000 m a.s.l.
  • 3,001-4,000 m a.s.l.
  • > 4,000 m a.s.l.
Technology is applied in
  • convex situations
  • concave situations
  • not relevant
Soil depth
  • very shallow (0-20 cm)
  • shallow (21-50 cm)
  • moderately deep (51-80 cm)
  • deep (81-120 cm)
  • very deep (> 120 cm)
Soil texture (topsoil)
  • coarse/ light (sandy)
  • medium (loamy, silty)
  • fine/ heavy (clay)
Soil texture (> 20 cm below surface)
  • coarse/ light (sandy)
  • medium (loamy, silty)
  • fine/ heavy (clay)
Topsoil organic matter content
  • high (>3%)
  • medium (1-3%)
  • low (<1%)
Groundwater table
  • on surface
  • < 5 m
  • 5-50 m
  • > 50 m
Availability of surface water
  • excess
  • good
  • medium
  • poor/ none
Water quality (untreated)
  • good drinking water
  • poor drinking water (treatment required)
  • for agricultural use only (irrigation)
  • unusable
Water quality refers to:
Is salinity a problem?
  • Yes
  • No

Occurrence of flooding
  • Yes
  • No
Species diversity
  • high
  • medium
  • low
Habitat diversity
  • high
  • medium
  • low

Characteristics of land users applying the Technology

Market orientation
  • subsistence (self-supply)
  • mixed (subsistence/ commercial)
  • commercial/ market
Off-farm income
  • less than 10% of all income
  • 10-50% of all income
  • > 50% of all income
Relative level of wealth
  • very poor
  • poor
  • average
  • rich
  • very rich
Level of mechanization
  • manual work
  • animal traction
  • mechanized/ motorized
Sedentary or nomadic
  • Sedentary
  • Semi-nomadic
  • Nomadic
  • During flood he cultivates at other places.
Individuals or groups
  • individual/ household
  • groups/ community
  • cooperative
  • employee (company, government)
Gender
  • women
  • men
Age
  • children
  • youth
  • middle-aged
  • elderly
Area used per household
  • < 0.5 ha
  • 0.5-1 ha
  • 1-2 ha
  • 2-5 ha
  • 5-15 ha
  • 15-50 ha
  • 50-100 ha
  • 100-500 ha
  • 500-1,000 ha
  • 1,000-10,000 ha
  • > 10,000 ha
Scale
  • small-scale
  • medium-scale
  • large-scale
Land ownership
  • state
  • company
  • communal/ village
  • group
  • individual, not titled
  • individual, titled
  • Hire
Land use rights
  • open access (unorganized)
  • communal (organized)
  • leased
  • individual
  • Hire
Water use rights
  • open access (unorganized)
  • communal (organized)
  • leased
  • individual
Access to services and infrastructure
health

poor
x
good
education

poor
x
good
technical assistance

poor
x
good
employment (e.g. off-farm)

poor
x
good
markets

poor
x
good
energy

poor
x
good
roads and transport

poor
x
good
drinking water and sanitation

poor
x
good
financial services

poor
x
good

Impacts

Socio-economic impacts
crop quality
decreased
x
increased


Using newspaper to wrap up is making the bitter melon healthier.

expenses on agricultural inputs
increased
x
decreased


The expenses on agricultural inputs are reduced due to less use of chemical fertilizer (little use of mixture of urea, animals manure and fish head fertilizer) and less expenses as instead of expensive nets he uses bamboo sticks and also he uses cheaper newspaper for fruit protection.

farm income
decreased
x
increased


The income is increased due to reduction of insects damaging.

workload
increased
x
decreased


It is increased a bit because he has to wrap up all fruits.

Socio-cultural impacts
Ecological impacts
pest/ disease control
decreased
x
increased


This newspaper wrap up technique controls only pest.

Off-site impacts
impact of greenhouse gases
increased
x
reduced


Reused of newspaper and bamboo branches for optimizing.

Cost-benefit analysis

Benefits compared with establishment costs
Short-term returns
very negative
x
very positive

Long-term returns
very negative
x
very positive

Benefits compared with maintenance costs
Short-term returns
very negative
x
very positive

Long-term returns
very negative
x
very positive

Looking for job sees to be less profitable than growing vegetables. Bitter melon can be harvested during half a month and could be cultivated twice a year.

Climate change

Gradual climate change
annual temperature increase

not well at all
x
very well
seasonal rainfall increase

not well at all
x
very well
Season: wet/ rainy season

Adoption and adaptation

Percentage of land users in the area who have adopted the Technology
  • single cases/ experimental
  • 1-10%
  • 11-50%
  • > 50%
Of all those who have adopted the Technology, how many have done so without receiving material incentives?
  • 0-10%
  • 11-50%
  • 51-90%
  • 91-100%
Number of households and/ or area covered
There are about 6 families in the village who practice this technique as well.
Has the Technology been modified recently to adapt to changing conditions?
  • Yes
  • No
To which changing conditions?
  • climatic change/ extremes
  • changing markets
  • labour availability (e.g. due to migration)

Conclusions and lessons learnt

Strengths: land user's view
  • Gain of a variety of benefits because they do not have to hire labor or buy bamboo sticks and they have animal manure.
  • Reduced use of chemical fertilizers as instead they are using fish head fertilizer.
Strengths: compiler’s or other key resource person’s view
  • Bamboo sticks do not cause additional costs because they can be gathered for free.
  • Using newspapers does not cause negative environmental impacts compared to the the use of plastic and it also reduces the need for pesticides.
  • Fish head fertilizer and animal manure helps to improve the soil’s fertility and reduces the need for chemical fertilizer.
  • Reduced cost of planting materials.
Weaknesses/ disadvantages/ risks: land user's viewhow to overcome
  • Pesticide was applied without protection of the fruit but it did not work. Wrap up bitter gourd in newspaper before applying pesticide and then check the fruit regularly.
  • No water in the pond during the dry season. Use water from the river by pumping instead.
  • Expense of buying pipes to pump water from a distant source. Borrow from others and take a loan from retailers.
  • Low market price of the bitter gourd. There is no solution for market yet.
Weaknesses/ disadvantages/ risks: compiler’s or other key resource person’s viewhow to overcome

References

Compiler
  • vann vun
Editors
  • Be Gechkim
  • Sok Pheak
  • Sophea Tim
  • Navin Chea
Reviewer
  • Ursula Gaemperli
  • SO Than
  • Nicole Harari
  • Cornelia Hett
  • Alexandra Gavilano
Date of documentation: April 25, 2017
Last update: Sept. 2, 2019
Resource persons
Full description in the WOCAT database
Linked SLM data
Documentation was faciliated by
Institution Project
Links to relevant information which is available online
This work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareaAlike 4.0 International