Transhumant livestock keeper in the region of Maradi. (VSF Belgium)

Management of transboundary transhumance (Niger)

Transboundary cooperation on transhumance

Description

Management of transboundary transhumance in order to create the conditions for conflict-free access to resources for livestock keeping in Niger and northern Benin.

This approach involves multiple actors, and is based on cooperation between them in the border region between Benin and Niger. The aim is to handle the concerns of livestock keepers practicing transhumance, who are victims of harassment and conflicts related to access to resources for livestock. It is a framework of exchange between the various actors in charge of managing the mobility of livestock keepers across the border.
The approach aims at the appropriation and application by the multiple stakeholders of the community legislation on transboundary transhumance - as adopted by the Economic Community of West African States (CEDEAO). The context is increased competition for access to natural resources, exacerbated by the effects of climate change. The approach consists of: (i) implementing a framework for cooperative management of transboundary transhumance between Benin and Niger; (ii) ensuring wide dissemination of community legislation of the CEDEAO on the management of the transhumance practices, and (iii) enabling conflict-free and sustainable access to resources for livestock keeping in the two countries.
The main methods used are: (i) the development of the Scheme for regional Land Management (SAF); (ii) building the necessary infrastructure for livestock keeping (marking of corridors and grazing areas, restoration and management of rangelands, establishment of vaccination centres, etc.); (iii) the raising of awareness among livestock keepers, through the organisation of livestock keepers on the ground (grassroots land commission, local committee of transhumance); (iv) the organisation of transboundary and local for a; and (v) monitoring of the implementation of recommendations forthcoming from the meetings.
The process took place in several stages: the actors of the civil society and the livestock keeping services first identified, together with the livestock keepers, the difficulties related to the transhumance in the two countries. Next they proceeded to inform the livestock keepers and farmers about the community legislation of the CEDEAO. Under the responsibility of the authorities of the two countries, transboundary and local fora were organized periodically to discuss difficulties related to transhumance. The census of all transhumant livestock keepers enabled facilitation of the delivery of travel documents (International Certificate of Transhumance - CIT - and identity document). The committee for receiving the transhumant livestock keepers was established and is functional. It is composed of municipalities, the civil society, and heads of the livestock keepers. Its role is to receive and guide the livestock keepers and to facilitate their stay. A mechanism has been put in place to monitor the implementation of the decisions and recommendations during the periodic meetings between the parties.
The regional council is the contracting authority, and ensures the general coordination of the process, and the monitoring of the recommendations. The administrative and customary authorities participate in information and awareness-raising of the population, and in the management of conflicts. The municipalities implement the recommendations and facilitate access to travel documents. The role of the civil society organisations is to watch the process, to identify the key actors, and to inform and make aware the leaders of the livestock keepers and the transhumant livestock keepers. The services for livestock keeping issue the International Certificate of Transhumance (CIT), and take part in awareness-raising and census of the transhumant livestock keepers. The land commissions secure the resources for livestock keeping. The water and forestry services provide information about the management of protected and listed resources. The Program to Support the Livestock Keeping Sector (PASEL7) finances the process and provides technical support.

The livestock keepers have appreciated the participatory and inclusive character of the approach, which has enabled them to share their concerns with all key actors, and to use their language (Fulfulde) in the exchange during the sessions of awareness-raising. The livestock keepers have also appreciated the selection of the municipality of Karimama in Benin as the main entrance zone to Benin for transhumant livestock keepers. However, the livestock keepers regretted the poor logistical organisation of the sessions for awareness-raising, which did not enable participation of the maximum number of livestock keepers in any of the municipalities in Niger.

Location

Location: Region of Dosso in Niger, and Department of Alibori in Benin, Niger

Geo-reference of selected sites
  • 3.44816, 11.88409

Initiation date: 2016

Year of termination: n.a.

Type of Approach
Awareness-raising of the leaders of transhumant livestock keepers in the municipality of Gaya in Niger. (Ousmane Oumarou Bako)
Demarcation of a corridor by the communities and the municipality of Dankassari in Niger. (Issaka Dan Dano)

Approach aims and enabling environment

Main aims / objectives of the approach
The objective of the approach is to achieve understanding, and application, of the community legislation on transboundary transhumance, which was adopted by the heads of State and Government of the Economic Community of West African States (CEDEAO) in order to prevent and reduce conflicts related to the mobility of livestock keeping, and to foster better use of resources for livestock keeping in the two countries.
Conditions enabling the implementation of the Technology/ ies applied under the Approach
  • Social/ cultural/ religious norms and values: Facilitate the arrangement of social agreements in the process of securing land resources for livestock keeping.
  • Availability/ access to financial resources and services: Availability of funding from the Program to Support the Livestock Keeping Sector (PASEL7) to organize the process.
  • Institutional setting: Emergence of new actors like the local and regional authorities in the two countries.
  • Collaboration/ coordination of actors: Existence of a framework for cooperation between multiple actors, and for synergy in actions, led by the Regional Council of Dosso.
  • Policies: Existence of laws and regulations governing the transboundary transhumance in the framework of the Economic Community of West African States (CEDEAO), and existence of an act on pastoralism and a rural code in Niger.
  • Land governance (decision-making, implementation and enforcement): Existence of functional decentralized structures in the rural code of Niger and within the region of Dosso.
Conditions hindering the implementation of the Technology/ ies applied under the Approach
  • Social/ cultural/ religious norms and values: The difficulties are most often related to the ignorance of herders accompanying animals in transhumance. They are illiterate and lack knowledge of the regulations on mobility across the border.
  • Availability/ access to financial resources and services: Weak mobilization of other funding sources to ensure the co-funding of the cross-border meetings.
  • Institutional setting: The meetings have not yet been formalized.

Participation and roles of stakeholders involved

Stakeholders involved in the Approach and their roles
What stakeholders / implementing bodies were involved in the Approach? Specify stakeholders Describe roles of stakeholders
local land users/ local communities Communities of Peul livestock keepers, generally young herders and their families. They provide the information and profit from the actions.
community-based organizations Grass-roots groups of livestock keepers, who are members of the umbrella organisations of livestock keepers (Association for the Revitalization of Livestock Keeping in Niger - AREN, National Federation of Livestock Keepers in Niger - FENEN Daddo, Group of Cultural Action and Development of Young Livestock Keepers - GAJEL) Awareness-raising and coaching of livestock keepers
SLM specialists/ agricultural advisers Decentralized services for livestock keeping Issue International Certificates of Transhumance (CIT), participate in the awareness-raising of the livestock keepers, conduct the census of transhumant livestock keepers, carry out the vaccination of the animals.
NGO Organizations of livestock keepers (NGOs and associations) Social mobilization and awareness-raising among the livestock keepers
local government Local and regional authorities: Regional Councils and municipalities Program management, general coordination of the process, facilitating the issuance of civil status documents
international organization Swiss cooperation in Niger Vétérinaires Sans Frontières, Belgium Funding the process Accompanying the process
Lead agency
n/a
Involvement of local land users/ local communities in the different phases of the Approach
none
passive
external support
interactive
self-mobilization
initiation/ motivation
x
The regional council planned the activity following discussions with livestock keepers from the region.
planning
x
Exchanges with the livestock keepers to specify problems and to suggest appropriate strategies and actions
implementation
x
The initiative to practice transhumance and the compliance with regulatory requirements are within the competence of the livestock keeper.
monitoring/ evaluation
x
The communities provide useful information and take decisions regarding solutions.
Flow chart

This scheme summarizes the organisation of the transboundary meetings, as set out in the description of the approach.

Author: Issaka Dan Dano
Decision-making on the selection of SLM Technology

Decisions were taken by

  • land users alone (self-initiative)
  • mainly land users, supported by SLM specialists
  • all relevant actors, as part of a participatory approach
  • mainly SLM specialists, following consultation with land users
  • SLM specialists alone
  • politicians/ leaders

Decisions were made based on

  • evaluation of well-documented SLM knowledge (evidence-based decision-making)
  • research findings
  • personal experience and opinions (undocumented)

Technical support, capacity building, and knowledge management

The following activities or services have been part of the approach
Advisory service
Advisory service was provided
  • on land users' fields
  • at permanent centres
  • in the settlements and grazing areas
The livestock keeping services provide useful information to the livestock keepers on transhumance and on enabling conditions. They issue the International Certificate of Transhumance to transhumant livestock keepers, after vaccinating their herds. They are present in the field to organize joint meetings to inform livestock keepers, and receive the leaders and livestock keepers who seek information in their offices. The Civil Society Organisations participate in these services, especially in the field, and support the mobilization of the community.
Institution strengthening
Institutions have been strengthened / established
  • no
  • yes, a little
  • yes, moderately
  • yes, greatly
at the following level
  • local
  • regional
  • national
  • transboundary level
Describe institution, roles and responsibilities, members, etc.
An advisory committee is established for transboundary transhumance, bringing together actors from Benin and from Niger. The committee is set to the level of the municipalities, the region and the border region. It includes the mayors, Civil Society Organisations of livestock keepers, the decentralized technical services, the land commissions and the leaders of the communities of livestock keepers.
Type of support
  • financial
  • capacity building/ training
  • equipment
  • guidance
Further details
The Program to Support the Livestock Keeping Sector (PASEL7) contributes to funding and provides guidance and support to the actors in the implementation of the process.
Monitoring and evaluation
The monitoring and evaluation are integrated in the steering of the process through periodic cross-border meetings, and are operated by the regional council with the support of PASEL7.

Financing and external material support

Annual budget in USD for the SLM component
  • < 2,000
  • 2,000-10,000
  • 10,000-100,000
  • 100,000-1,000,000
  • > 1,000,000
Precise annual budget: n.a.
The funding is provided by PASEL7, a program financed by the Swiss Cooperation in Niger, and implemented under the lead of VSF-Belgium. In the long term, it is envisaged that the actors themselves will be fully in charge of financing the approach.
The following services or incentives have been provided to land users
  • Financial/ material support provided to land users
  • Subsidies for specific inputs
  • Credit
  • Other incentives or instruments

Impact analysis and concluding statements

Impacts of the Approach
No
Yes, little
Yes, moderately
Yes, greatly
Did the Approach empower local land users, improve stakeholder participation?

The compliance with the procedures for transhumance, as defined by the CEDEAO, has slightly improved. Hence the number of International Certificates of Transhumance issued since the start of the approach has increased from 6 to 216.

x
Did the Approach enable evidence-based decision-making?

The meeting takes informed decisions based on consultation with the livestock keepers and the administrative and customary authorities. Initially interviews were held to collect the needs and information from the livestock keepers.

x
Did the Approach improve knowledge and capacities of other stakeholders?

The livestock keepers have better understood the community regulations (CEDEAO) on transhumance, and the challenges of compliance.

x
Did the Approach build/ strengthen institutions, collaboration between stakeholders?

The different stakeholders collaborate regularly and exchange information, which facilitates the management of the transhumance on either side between Benin and Niger.

x
Did the Approach mitigate conflicts?

There has been a sharp decrease in conflicts between farmers and livestock keepers, as well as acts of violence towards the transhumant livestock keepers. Before the approach was implemented, there were regular arrests by the border authorities in Niger for conflicts related to transbounday transhumance; these have now become sporadic.

x
Did the Approach improve issues of land tenure/ user rights that hindered implementation of SLM Technologies?

The approach has enabled the clarification of the ownership status of certain grazing areas, and has strengthened the proportional representation of the grass-roots land commissions.

x
Did the Approach improve access to markets?

Free movement across the border of the transhumant livestock keepers facilitates the access to the livestock markets in northern Benin. As a result, livestock keepers are now well supplied with live cattle.

x
Did the Approach improve the capacity of the land users to adapt to climate changes/ extremes and mitigate climate related disasters?

Transhumance is a strategy for resilience of Sahelian livestock production systems, by facilitating the access to grazing land for Sahelian livestock keepers in bordering countries.

x
Main motivation of land users to implement SLM
Sustainability of Approach activities
Can the land users sustain what hat been implemented through the Approach (without external support)?

The approach has fostered contacts between the actors involved; they only need to ensure their continued accountability. The results which have already been achieved will enable actors to sustain the approach in the long term. Considerations will be made on how to secure funding by the actors themselves. The Land Management Scheme will serve to guide such an approach to manage the mobility of livestock keeping.

Conclusions and lessons learnt

Strengths: land user's view
  • Flexibility in the acquisition of civil status documents and of the International Certificate of Transhumance
  • Effective involvement of the authorities of Niger and Benin
  • Reconciliation of the leaders of livestock keepers, the Civil Society Organisations and the border authorities of the two countries
Strengths: compiler’s or other key resource person’s view
Weaknesses/ disadvantages/ risks: land user's viewhow to overcome
  • Weak feedback of recommendations in Benin Informing the established monitoring committee in writing
  • Insufficient information on the boundaries of the protected and listed areas in Benin
Weaknesses/ disadvantages/ risks: compiler’s or other key resource person’s viewhow to overcome
  • There is a high risk that the approach will be abandoned or becomes irregular after the end of the PASEL7 project. Support to the mobilization of other partners is ongoing.
  • The lack of supplies in the forms for the International Certificate of Transhumance frequently slows down their issuance. The Regional Directorate for Livestock Keeping makes arrangements to ensure the availability of forms in the period of preparation for the transhumance.

References

Compiler
  • Issaka DAN DANO
Editors
Reviewer
  • Rima Mekdaschi Studer
  • Simone Verzandvoort
  • Joana Eichenberger
Date of documentation: June 28, 2017
Last update: Nov. 2, 2021
Resource persons
Full description in the WOCAT database
Linked SLM data
Documentation was faciliated by
Institution Project
Key references
  • Guide Méthodologique: Processus d'élaboration du schéma d’aménagement foncier (SAF), Secrétariat permanent du code rural Niger, avril 2011: Ministry of Agriculture and Livestock Keeping, Permanent secretary of the rural code in Niger
  • Conflits fonciers ruraux au Niger: les mécanismes de prévention et de gestion, Secrétariat permanent du code rural Niger, édition 2014: Ministry of Agriculture and Livestock Keeping, Permanent secretary of the rural code in Niger
  • Recueil des textes sur le pastoralisme, Secrétariat permanent du code rural Niger, mai 2014 : Ministry of Agriculture and Livestock Keeping, Permanent secretary of the rural code in Niger
  • Sécurisation des Espaces Pastoraux, Programme d'Appui au secteur de l’élevage phase 6 (PASEL6), 2015: VSF-Belgium in Niger
  • Capitalisation sur les stratégies et adaptation aux évolutions du contexte, PASEL6, 2015: VSF-Belgium in Niger
  • Opérationnalité des structures du code rural, PASEL6, 2015: VSF-Belgium in Niger
  • Accompagnement des acteurs sur le SAF, PASEL6, 2015: VSF-Belgium in Niger
This work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareaAlike 4.0 International