Maintenance mowing of a new planting of a windbreak (Hanns Kirchmeir)

Rehabilitation of Windbreaks (乔治亚)

描述

Windbreaks are an integrated technology to increase land productivity and biodiversity at different levels. Along six kilometres, located between a road and agricultural fields, windbreaks were rehabilitated or newly established to protect the soil wind erosion. Four lines of seedlings including seven tree species were planted in two meters distance to each other. The survival rates of different tree species have been accessed and evaluated.

Agriculture plays a key role in the economy of Georgia. 74% of wheat is produced in Kakheti. Within the region, the main wheat-growing area is Shiraki valley located in Dedoplistskaro Municipality in Eastern Georgia. The valley has deep soil with high humus content offering significant potential for high agricultural yields. Among others, wind erosion and increase of evaporation due to degradation of windbreaks have led to reduced agricultural yields. At the end of the Soviet Union, there were 1.800 km of tree windbreaks in Shiraki. More than 90% of them were destroyed either by fire or illegal cuttings for firewood. Fires are caused by farmers burning harvest residues and by shepherds burning pastures and windbreaks to facilitate the growth of new grass and clear land. Today, fire still pose the greatest threat to the rehabilitation of windbreaks. Grazing by migrating sheep and by local (cattle) herds as well as firewood extraction is still causing additional damage to windbreaks in specific areas of Shiraki valley.

In Dedoplistskaro, the SLM-pilot activities focus on the establishment of a windbreak/agroforestry system to reduce wind erosion, which is here the main degradation factor and threatens agricultural production. Windbreaks are a well-known measure against wind erosion. They consist of several rows of trees and bushes on the edges of agricultural fields to reduce the wind-speed on the surface level. Slowing down of wind-speed protects the topsoil from wind erosion. Windbreaks improve the micro-climate for crops growing in their shelter by reducing moisture loss. Windbreaks also provide shelter and habitats for a wide range of plants, pollinating insects, wildlife and birds, including predators of agricultural pests.

Selection of seedlings:

Tree species well adapted to the regional conditions (climate, soil, etc.) were selected such as Pinus (Pinus eldarica, survival rate: 90%), Pistacia (Pistacia mutica, survival rate 60%) and Elm (Ulmus minor, survival rate 60%), Wild Almond (Prunus argentea, survival rate 40%), Persian olive (Eleagnus angustifolia, survival rate: 40%) and Robinia (Robinia pseudoacacia, survival rate 16%). The survival rates are based on the assessment in September 2018, 6 months after planting.

The seeds were prepared for planting in a nursery. Seedlings to be transported over long distances must be grown in special containers to ensure good root system development and minimise damage during transport. If they are grown near the planting site and the transport time is short, seedlings may also be bare-rooted.

Preparation of soil and planting:
The pilot site of the project "Applying Landscape and Sustainable Land Management (L-SLM) for Mitigating Land Degradation and Contributing to Poverty Reduction in Rural Areas", implemented by the Regional Environment Centre for the Caucasus, is six km long and located on the main road on state-owned land. Before planting the seedlings, the vegetation (grass and herbs) was cut and removed. No ploughing was done. During the implementation in 2018, the design of the site was changed to a 6 km long U-shaped form with three 10 m wide segments of windbreaks. The total area of the pilot site is 6 ha, but since there were already intact hedges in some parts, the total area where windbreaks were either newly planted or rehabilitated is 3 ha. Each windbreak consisted of four lines of tree seedlings of different species in two meters distance to each other (inter-row spacing) and 2 m distance between the seedlings within a row (intra-row spacing). First, holes were dug (30 cm diameter, 40 cm deep), then water accumulation granulate was added to keep the water better, then the seedlings of 10-40 cm height and 2-3 years old depending on species were inserted. No compost or fertiliser was used. The seedlings were protected by plastic tubes from the cold and dry winter season. Every 2nd seedling was marked with a wooden pole to distinguish them from weeds and to control the survival rate. If the survival rate falls below 50%, the trees should be replaced. After the planting of the seedling, the herbs and grass were cut again. Further cuttings took place several times to avoid shading and competition.

Maintenance

Besides cutting of weeds for 2 times in the main growing season (Mai-July) regular watering was applied. Young seedlings should be watered 2-4 times per year (first 2 years) – about 15-20l per tree. After 2 years the root system should be established in such a way that it can take care of itself. The implementation area was not fenced, but there is no pastureland around and pressure by browsing is low.

The Regional Environment Centre for the Caucasus (REC) in cooperation with GIZ has conducted a cost-benefit analysis to estimate the value of protecting remaining windbreaks, the economic impact of banning crop residue burning and the benefits of straw as a fertilizer. The survey data shows that a ban on crop residue burning will help to protect the existing windbreaks. Consequently, shredding of straw during the harvest and subsequent incorporation of straw into the soil builds up soil organic matter and helps to retain the moisture in the ground. Unclear ownership and institutional responsibility are the most relevant constraints for sustainable windbreaks management as a measure. At the political level, issues were noted, and steps were taken: A working group under the National Forest Programme selected windbreaks restoration and protection as their key topics. The Ministry of Environmental Protection and Agriculture with the support from REC and GIZ developed a policy for rehabilitation and protection of windbreaks. Based on this, a new law on windbreaks was initiated which will clarify the situation by ascribing clear responsibilities on windbreak maintenance and management. This law is still at the stage of preparation in the Agrarian Committee.

地点

地点: Dedoplistskaro, Kakheti, 乔治亚

分析的技术场所数量: 单一场所

选定地点的地理参考
  • 46.25252, 41.40968

技术传播: 适用于特定场所/集中在较小区域

在永久保护区?:

实施日期: 2018

介绍类型
Intact windbreaks between crop fields (Hanns Kirchmeir)
Removal of dry biomass (Hanns Kirchmeir)

技术分类

主要目的
  • 改良生产
  • 减少、预防、恢复土地退化
  • 保护生态系统
  • 结合其他技术保护流域/下游区域
  • 保持/提高生物多样性
  • 降低灾害风险
  • 适应气候变化/极端天气及其影响
  • 减缓气候变化及其影响
  • 创造有益的经济影响
  • 创造有益的社会影响
土地利用
同一土地单元内混合使用的土地: 是 - 农林业

  • 农田
    • 一年一作: 谷类 - 大麦, 谷类 - 小麦(春季), 谷类 - 小麦(冬季)
    每年的生长季节数: 2
    采用间作制度了吗?: 否
    采用轮作制度了吗?: 否
  • 森林/林地
    • 植树造林: 温带草原人工林. 品种: 混交品种
    Tree types (混合落叶或常绿): 松树属, Ulmus minor, Pinus eldarica, Elaeagnus angustifolia, Cotinus coggygria , Pistacia mutica, Ulmus minor, Robinia pseudoacacia, Prunus argentea
    产品和服务: 薪材, 自然保持/保护, 自然灾害防护, Protection soil from wind erosion

供水
  • 雨养
  • 混合雨水灌溉
  • 充分灌溉

土地退化相关的目的
  • 防止土地退化
  • 减少土地退化
  • 修复/恢复严重退化的土地
  • 适应土地退化
  • 不适用
解决的退化问题
  • 土壤风蚀 - Et:表土流失
  • 水质恶化 - Ha:干旱化
SLM组
  • 农业林学
  • 防风林/防护林带
SLM措施
  • 植物措施 - V1:乔木和灌木覆盖层

技术图纸

技术规范
Location of windbreaks along the main and side roads. During implementation the design of the site was changed to an u-shaped form built by 3 windbreaks. The windbreaks that are included in the rehabilitation were segmented into four:
Windbreak A1 - Replanting new seedlings - 458 length (m);
Windbreak A2 - Removal of dry biomass - 403 length (m);
Windbreak B - Replanting new seedlings - 2.560 length (m);
Windbreak C - Replanting new seedlings - 2.354 length (m).
While in the segments A1, B and C the tree cover is very low and new seedlings are needed, in segment A2 there is still a dense crown cover.

To protect the existing trees in segment A2, the dry biomass under the crown (dry herbs and grass, dead trees & branches) was removed to reduce the amount of fuel in the case of a fire. This process was just started at the north end of A2.
In Segment B Pistacia mutica, Ulmus minor, Robinia pseudoacacia, Cotinus coggygria and Wild almond (Prunus argentea) have been planted.
In Segment C Pinus eldarica, Elaeagnus angustifolia Pistacia mutica, Ulmus minor, Robinia pseudoacacia and Wild almond (Prunus argentea) have been planted.
Author: Hanns Kirchmeir
Planting scheme for windbreaks rehabilitation.
The distance between the lines is 2m and the distance between seedlings within a line is also 2m. About every second seedling is marked with a wooden pole (50 cm). This is done on the one hand to control the survival rate (if every second seedling is, the next seedling is only 2m away and easy to find) and on the other hand to identify and leave the seedlings standing when the weeds are cleared.
Author: Hanns Kirchmeir

技术建立与维护:活动、投入和费用

投入和成本的计算
  • 计算的成本为:每个技术区域 (尺寸和面积单位:3 ha
  • 成本计算使用的货币:GEL
  • 汇率(换算为美元):1 美元 = 2.7 GEL
  • 雇用劳工的每日平均工资成本:15 USD
影响成本的最重要因素
How often weeds need to be cut, survival rate of trees
技术建立活动
  1. Marking sites in the field (时间/频率: April-May)
  2. Cut grass and remove dead wood (时间/频率: April)
  3. Planting of seedlings (planting, adding wooden poles and water accumulation granulate (时间/频率: April-May)
  4. Irrigation and weed-cutting (时间/频率: July, August (to be repeated for 3 years))
  5. Scientific Monitoring (时间/频率: October - October (five years))
技术建立的投入和成本 (per 3 ha)
对投入进行具体说明 单位 数量 单位成本 (GEL) 每项投入的总成本 (GEL) 土地使用者承担的成本%
劳动力
Clearing and preparation of sites (3 ha) person days 40.0 30.0 1200.0
Weed cutting 2 x on 3 ha person days 110.0 36.0 3960.0
Planting of 7.300 seedlings (digging hole, adding water accumulation granulate, planting seedling, adding wooden pole and tube) person days 73.0 45.0 3285.0
Irrigation 4 x 7.300 seedlings person days 73.0 75.0 5475.0
设备
Wooden poles pieces 7300.0 0.9 6570.0
Water accumulation granulate kg 73.0 70.0 5110.0
Water for irrigation 300.0 3.0 900.0
Transport of water (water truck) applications 4.0 1300.0 5200.0
植物材料
Pistacia mutica pieces 470.0 3.0 1410.0
Robinia pseudoacacia pieces 1825.0 1.0 1825.0
Pinus eldarica pieces 117.0 5.0 585.0
Ulmus minor pieces 1355.0 2.0 2710.0
Amygdalus communis pieces 1238.0 1.0 1238.0
Elaeagnus angustifolia pieces 1237.0 0.75 927.75
其它
Transportation of workers and materials by lorry transfers 50.0 60.0 3000.0
技术建立所需总成本 43'395.75
技术建立总成本,美元 16'072.5
技术维护活动
  1. Watering the seedlings (时间/频率: Every 2-3 weeks during dry period in July-September)
  2. Preparing fire-break around windbreak (时间/频率: August, after harvesting the crops)
  3. Weed cutting between seedlings (时间/频率: 1-2 times between June and August)
  4. Replacing dead trees by new seedlings (if needed) (时间/频率: October/November)
技术维护的投入和成本 (per 3 ha)
对投入进行具体说明 单位 数量 单位成本 (GEL) 每项投入的总成本 (GEL) 土地使用者承担的成本%
劳动力
Weed cutting 2 times on 3 ha person days 110.0 37.0 4070.0
Irrigation 4*7.300 seedlings person days 73.0 75.0 5475.0
Protect firebreak around windbreak person days 4.0 100.0 400.0
设备
Water (10l/seedling*4) 300.0 3.0 900.0
Transport of water (water truck) application 4.0 1300.0 5200.0
技术维护所需总成本 16'045.0
技术维护总成本,美元 5'942.59

自然环境

年平均降雨量
  • < 250毫米
  • 251-500毫米
  • 501-750毫米
  • 751-1,000毫米
  • 1,001-1,500毫米
  • 1,501-2,000毫米
  • 2,001-3,000毫米
  • 3,001-4,000毫米
  • > 4,000毫米
农业气候带
  • 潮湿的
  • 半湿润
  • 半干旱
  • 干旱
关于气候的规范
以毫米为单位计算的年平均降雨量:697.0
The driest month is January, with 25 mm of rainfall. The greatest amount of precipitation occurs in June, with an average of 108 mm. The difference in precipitation between the driest month and the wettest month is 83 mm.
气象站名称:Dedoplistskaro Met. Station
The climate is warm and temperate in Dedoplistskaro. The average annual temperature in Dedoplistskaro is 11.3 °C. The warmest month of the year is July, with an average temperature of 22.7 °C. The lowest average temperatures in the year occur in January, when it is around 0.1 °C.
斜坡
  • 水平(0-2%)
  • 缓降(3-5%)
  • 平缓(6-10%)
  • 滚坡(11-15%)
  • 崎岖(16-30%)
  • 陡峭(31-60%)
  • 非常陡峭(>60%)
地形
  • 高原/平原
  • 山脊
  • 山坡
  • 山地斜坡
  • 麓坡
  • 谷底
海拔
  • 0-100 m a.s.l.
  • 101-500 m a.s.l.
  • 501-1,000 m a.s.l.
  • 1,001-1,500 m a.s.l.
  • 1,501-2,000 m a.s.l.
  • 2,001-2,500 m a.s.l.
  • 2,501-3,000 m a.s.l.
  • 3,001-4,000 m a.s.l.
  • > 4,000 m a.s.l.
......应用的技术
  • 凸形情况
  • 凹陷情况
  • 不相关
土壤深度
  • 非常浅(0-20厘米)
  • 浅(21-50厘米)
  • 中等深度(51-80厘米)
  • 深(81-120厘米)
  • 非常深(> 120厘米)
土壤质地(表土)
  • 粗粒/轻(砂质)
  • 中粒(壤土、粉土)
  • 细粒/重质(粘土)
土壤质地(地表以下>20厘米)
  • 粗粒/轻(砂质)
  • 中粒(壤土、粉土)
  • 细粒/重质(粘土)
表土有机质含量
  • 高(>3%)
  • 中(1-3%)
  • 低(<1%)
地下水位
  • 表面上
  • < 5米
  • 5-50米
  • > 50米
地表水的可用性
  • 过量
  • 中等
  • 匮乏/没有
水质(未处理)
  • 良好饮用水
  • 不良饮用水(需要处理)
  • 仅供农业使用(灌溉)
  • 不可用
水质请参考: 地下水
盐度是个问题吗?

洪水发生
物种多样性
  • 中等
栖息地多样性
  • 中等

应用该技术的土地使用者的特征

市场定位
  • 生计(自给)
  • 混合(生计/商业)
  • 商业/市场
非农收入
  • 低于全部收入的10%
  • 收入的10-50%
  • > 收入的50%
相对财富水平
  • 非常贫瘠
  • 贫瘠
  • 平均水平
  • 丰富
  • 非常丰富
机械化水平
  • 手工作业
  • 畜力牵引
  • 机械化/电动
定栖或游牧
  • 定栖的
  • 半游牧的
  • 游牧的
个人或集体
  • 个人/家庭
  • 团体/社区
  • 合作社
  • 员工(公司、政府)
性别
  • 女人
  • 男人
年龄
  • 儿童
  • 青年人
  • 中年人
  • 老年人
每户使用面积
  • < 0.5 公顷
  • 0.5-1 公顷
  • 1-2 公顷
  • 2-5公顷
  • 5-15公顷
  • 15-50公顷
  • 50-100公顷
  • 100-500公顷
  • 500-1,000公顷
  • 1,000-10,000公顷
  • > 10,000公顷
规模
  • 小规模的
  • 中等规模的
  • 大规模的
土地所有权
  • 公司
  • 社区/村庄
  • 团体
  • 个人,未命名
  • 个人,有命名
土地使用权
  • 自由进入(无组织)
  • 社区(有组织)
  • 租赁
  • 个人
用水权
  • 自由进入(无组织)
  • 社区(有组织)
  • 租赁
  • 个人
进入服务和基础设施的通道
健康

贫瘠
教育

贫瘠
技术援助

贫瘠
就业(例如非农)

贫瘠
市场

贫瘠
能源

贫瘠
道路和交通

贫瘠
饮用水和卫生设施

贫瘠
金融服务

贫瘠

影响

社会经济影响
作物生产
降低
增加


The positive effect on crop yields will be visible when trees in the windbreak get higher than 3 meters.

木材生产
降低
增加


First harvest of firewood is expected in 15-20 years

社会文化影响
生态影响
蒸发
增加
降低


Due to an expected reduction in wind speed near the ground, the evaporation rate is expected to decrease after the trees have reached a height of more than 5 m. So far, no data from measurements are available.

土壤水分
降低
增加


Due to an expected reduction in wind speed near the ground, the evapotranspiration rate is expected to decrease after the trees have reached a height of more than 5 m, which would lead to an increase in soil moisture. So far, no data from measurements are available.

土壤流失
增加
降低


Due to the reduction in wind speed, it is expected that the amount of soil erosion caused by wind will decrease when the trees have reached a height of more than 5 m.

植物多样性
降低
增加


Windbreaks are refuge areas for plant species sensitive to herbicides and plowing.

动物多样性
降低
增加


The windbreaks provide shelter and breeding habitat for birds and small mammals. Tree litter improves soil conditions and has positive effect on soil-invertebrate diversity.

风速
增加
降低


The expected impact is a reduction of wind velocity up to 200 m after the windbreak, which will lead to reduced wind erosion of top soil. This effect is related to tree height and will need 2-3 decades to gain full impact.

微气候
恶化
改良


The expected impact is a reduction of wind velocity up to 200m after the windbreak, which will lead to a decrease in evaporation. This effect is related to tree height and will need 2-3 decades to gain full Impact.

场外影响
风力搬运沉积物
增加
减少


By reducing the wind speed, the amount of soil erosion by wind is expected to decrease when the trees have reached a height of more than 5 m. The positive influence on the neighbouring field can be observed up to a distance of twice the height of the trees.

对邻近农田的破坏
增加
减少


By reducing the wind speed, the amount of soil erosion by wind is expected to decrease when the trees have reached a height of more than 5 m. The positive influence on the neighbouring field can be observed up to a distance of twice the height of the trees.

温室气体的影响
增加
减少

SLM之前的数量: 10 t CO2-eqiv/ha
SLM之后的数量: 200 t CO2-eqiv/ha
The increase in the volume of wood on the windbreak increases carbon storage in the ecosystem. The rehabilitation of a completely destroyed windbreak can increase the biomass volume by 100-200 m³/ha, which corresponds to 100-200 t carbon dioxide.

成本效益分析

与技术建立成本相比的效益
短期回报
非常消极
非常积极

长期回报
非常消极
非常积极

与技术维护成本相比的效益
短期回报
非常消极
非常积极

长期回报
非常消极
非常积极

It is a significant investment to establish a windbreak and it takes several years (5-10) before the measure will show effects on the increase of crop fields' productivity. But when established, the windbreak does not need investment for maintenance but can deliver additional benefit (fuel wood).

气候变化

渐变气候
年温度 增加

非常不好
非常好
年降雨量 减少

非常不好
非常好

采用和适应

采用该技术的地区内土地使用者的百分比
  • 单例/实验
  • 1-10%
  • 11-50%
  • > 50%
在所有采用这种技术的人当中,有多少人在没有获得物质奖励的情况下采用了这种技术?
  • 0-10%
  • 11-50%
  • 51-90%
  • 91-100%
最近是否对该技术进行了修改以适应不断变化的条件?
什么样的变化条件?
  • 气候变化/极端气候
  • 不断变化的市场
  • 劳动力可用性(例如,由于迁移)
The selection of tree species and planting technologies was adapted to the rising temperatures. Special protection tubes against winter storms were used.

结论和吸取的教训

长处: 土地使用者的观点
  • Increase of yields in the neighbouring fields
  • Availability of firewood
长处: 编制者或其他关键资源人员的观点
  • Seedlings can be produced locally in tree nurseries using local tree species.
  • Increase of protection from wind erosion and drought by wind impact.
  • Increase of habitat diversity
弱点/缺点/风险: 土地使用者的观点如何克服
  • Fires protecting the windbreak by ploughing the soil along the line
  • Lack of maintenance of planted seedlings cutting the grass and removing it from the field, continue mulching and watering the seedlings over the next few years, replanting the dead seedlings
弱点/缺点/风险: 编制者或其他关键资源人员的观点如何克服
  • High investment for seedlings, wooden poles and irrigation It is much cheaper to protect existing windbreaks from burning. Integrating fruit trees and/or vegetables into the windbreak can result in a faster return on investment.

参考文献

编制者
  • Hanns Kirchmeir
Editors
  • Kety Tsereteli
审查者
  • Rima Mekdaschi Studer
实施日期: Dec. 18, 2018
上次更新: Feb. 19, 2020
资源人
WOCAT数据库中的完整描述
链接的SLM数据
文件编制者
机构 项目
主要参考文献
  • Applying Landscape and Sustainable Land Management (L-SLM) for mitigating land degradation and contributing to poverty reduction in rural areas - Implementation Evaluation Report June 2018 – Windbreaks.:
链接到网络上可用的相关信息
This work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareaAlike 4.0 International