Cover crops in Brittany, France (Soil Care)

Vegetation cover management on an organic, mixed livestock-crop farm (法国)

描述

Use of different mixes of plant cover for livestock fodder which are simultaneously favourable for biodiversity by improving soil health, and reducing the need for agrochemicals.

Agriculture in Brittany, in the north-west of France, is known for fish, beef, pork, poultry, vegetables and milk. Cover crops are used by farmers of Mauron, and the example described here is from a farm located in Morbihan in the basin known as Ploërmel. In this warm temperate area the average annual rainfall is 650-700 mm with an annual temperature of around 11°C.
There are three types of cover crops included in the rotation. These are selected on the basis of their benefits in relation to soil fertility and fodder production, in order to improve the farm's food self-sufficiency. There are three basic types of cover crops, as follows.
1) “Protein mixes” are composed of 35% faba (broad) beans, 26% oats, 17.5% peas, 17.5% vetch, and 4% clover. These are sown in early October after grass or maize are made into silage at the end of April.
2) "Green manure" cover crops are sown at the beginning of September after cereals, and are composed of various complementary species with the main objective of preserving and strengthening soil life (i.e. worm abundance), and winter feeding of heifers. For example, the commercial "Biomax" mix contains seeds of broad bean, vetch, clover, phacelia and radish. These cover crops are enriched by the presence of approximately 50% ryegrass regrowth, supporting the development of soil life.
3) Rapeseed is sown after cereals as a crop rotation feedstock and are made into silage.
Cover crops are either broadcast and rolled, or direct seeded depending on the conditions of the post-harvest plots. The seed drill used is equipped with discs to minimise soil disturbance as a reduced tillage technique, but more important in this respect is the presence of crop residues (i.e. straw). The seed drill is also equipped with tines.
The cover crops are grazed by heifers in a rotational 2-day paddock set-up. After grazing and regrowth of the ryegrass present, the fields may be left to develop into pasture, or seeded to crops using a minimum tillage drill.
The purposes are:
•Improved production
•Countered land degradation
•Protected watersheds
•Preserved biodiversity
•Adaptation to climate change/extreme events
The benefits are:
•Sustained ecosystem health: no pest and disease problems, good herd health
•Enrichment of the soil by the addition of carbon in organic matter and by the work of earthworms - favouring ecosystem functioning
•Protection of the soil and surface biodiversity because of maintained plant cover
•Increased weed control due to plant canopies and fertilisation effect of green manure
•Planted cover crops used as livestock feed during winter
The challenges are:
•Potential difficulties in establishing plant cover (especially in dry areas)
•Late sowing of cover crops reduces beneficial effects
•High costs of seed mixtures with high protein cover crops

地点

地点: Mauron, Brittany, 法国

分析的技术场所数量: 单一场所

选定地点的地理参考
  • -2.3189, 48.06079

技术传播: 均匀地分布在一个区域 (approx. 10-100 平方千米)

在永久保护区?:

实施日期: 2019; 不到10年前(最近)

介绍类型
Cover crops in Brittany, France (Soil Care)
Cover crop mowing for its removal

技术分类

主要目的
  • 改良生产
  • 减少、预防、恢复土地退化
  • 保护生态系统
  • 结合其他技术保护流域/下游区域
  • 保持/提高生物多样性
  • 降低灾害风险
  • 适应气候变化/极端天气及其影响
  • 减缓气候变化及其影响
  • 创造有益的经济影响
  • 创造有益的社会影响
土地利用
同一土地单元内混合使用的土地: 是 - 农牧业(包括农牧结合)

  • 农田
    • 一年一作: 谷物类 - 玉米, 谷类 - 黑麦, 饲料作物 - 三叶草, 饲料作物 - 草, 饲料作物 - 其他, 豆科牧草和豆类 - 豆子, 油料作物 - 向日葵、菜籽、其他
    • Cover crops
    每年的生长季节数: 1
    采用间作制度了吗?: 是
    采用轮作制度了吗?: 是
  • 牧场
    • 收割和携带/零放牧
    • 改良牧场
    动物类型: 牛 - 奶制品, 家禽
    是否实行作物与牲畜的综合管理?: 是
      品种计数
      牛 - 奶制品115
      家禽4500
    供水
    • 雨养
    • 混合雨水灌溉
    • 充分灌溉

    土地退化相关的目的
    • 防止土地退化
    • 减少土地退化
    • 修复/恢复严重退化的土地
    • 适应土地退化
    • 不适用
    解决的退化问题
    • 土壤水蚀 - Wt:表土流失/地表侵蚀 , Wg:冲沟侵蚀/沟蚀 , Wo:场外劣化效应
    • 化学性土壤退化 - Cn:肥力下降和有机质含量下降(非侵蚀所致)
    • 物理性土壤退化 - Pc:压实
    • 生物性退化 - Bc:植被覆盖的减少, Bq:数量/生物量减少, Bs:质量和物种组成/多样性的下降, Bp:害虫/疾病增加,捕食者减少
    • 水质恶化 - Hp:地表水水质下降, Hw:湿地缓冲能力下降
    SLM组
    • 农畜综合管理
    • 改良的地面/植被覆盖
    • 病虫害综合管理(包括有机农业)
    SLM措施
    • 农艺措施 - A1:植被和土壤覆盖层, A2:有机质/土壤肥力, A3:土壤表面处理, A4:地表下处理

    技术图纸

    技术规范
    - broadcast sowing or direct sowing of species mixture in late August / early September or late September / early October
    - protein mix: peas 40 kg / faba (broad) beans 80 kg / vetch 40 kg / clover 8 kg / oats 60 kg per hectare
    - Biomax mix: radish 2 kg / clover 3 kg / faba (broad) bean 20 kg / phacelia 2 kg / vetch 10 kg per hectare
    - Rapeseed mix: 8 to 10 kg per hectare
    Author: Revue agricole Terra

    技术建立与维护:活动、投入和费用

    投入和成本的计算
    • 计算的成本为:每个技术区域 (尺寸和面积单位:1 ha
    • 成本计算使用的货币:
    • 汇率(换算为美元):1 美元 = 0.9 €
    • 雇用劳工的每日平均工资成本:Gross hourly minimum wage: €10.15 on 1 January 2020, i.e. €1,539.42 monthly on the basis of the legal working week of 35 hours.
    影响成本的最重要因素
    Direct sowing equipment, destruction with 2 passes of rolling spade, cost of purchasing "biomax" mixture
    技术建立活动
    1. Soil preparation and subsequent sowing of rapeseed/rapeseed after harvest cereals (时间/频率: End of August)
    2. Soil preparation and sowing of the Biomax mixture after harvest cereals (时间/频率: End of August)
    3. Soil preparation and sowing of meslin after grassland or corn on the cob (时间/频率: End of October)
    4. Rapeseed/rapeseed grazing and growing of green manure (时间/频率: December to March)
    5. Meslin silage (时间/频率: April)
    技术建立的投入和成本 (per 1 ha)
    对投入进行具体说明 单位 数量 单位成本 (€) 每项投入的总成本 (€) 土地使用者承担的成本%
    设备
    Direct seeding (compil) ha 40.0 60.0 2400.0 100.0
    Broadcast sowing ha 72.0 15.0 1080.0 100.0
    Roller spade before sowing (1 pass) ha 72.0 23.0 1656.0 100.0
    Maceration by a roller with blades ha 224.0 23.0 5152.0 100.0
    植物材料
    Seeds - protein blend ha 60.0 394.0 23640.0 100.0
    Seeds - forage rapeseed ha 17.0 28.0 476.0 100.0
    Seeds - green manure "biomax" fertilizer ha 18.0 60.0 1080.0 100.0
    技术建立所需总成本 35'484.0
    技术建立总成本,美元 39'426.67
    技术维护活动
    n.a.

    自然环境

    年平均降雨量
    • < 250毫米
    • 251-500毫米
    • 501-750毫米
    • 751-1,000毫米
    • 1,001-1,500毫米
    • 1,501-2,000毫米
    • 2,001-3,000毫米
    • 3,001-4,000毫米
    • > 4,000毫米
    农业气候带
    • 潮湿的
    • 半湿润
    • 半干旱
    • 干旱
    关于气候的规范
    以毫米为单位计算的年平均降雨量:675.0
    The farm is located on the commune of Mauron in Morbihan and is in an early agro-climatic zone. The average annual rainfall of 650-700 mm is the lowest in Morbihan. The average annual temperature of around 11°C and is also the lowest in Morbihan.
    气象站名称:Ploermel
    The climate of Mauron is warm and temperate. It is in the basin known as Ploërmel, the most continental of Morbihan with colder winters, hotter summers and rainfall of around 650-700 mm/year. Heavy showers fall all year round in the area of Mauron. Even in the driest months, rainfall remains fairly heavy.
    斜坡
    • 水平(0-2%)
    • 缓降(3-5%)
    • 平缓(6-10%)
    • 滚坡(11-15%)
    • 崎岖(16-30%)
    • 陡峭(31-60%)
    • 非常陡峭(>60%)
    地形
    • 高原/平原
    • 山脊
    • 山坡
    • 山地斜坡
    • 麓坡
    • 谷底
    海拔
    • 0-100 m a.s.l.
    • 101-500 m a.s.l.
    • 501-1,000 m a.s.l.
    • 1,001-1,500 m a.s.l.
    • 1,501-2,000 m a.s.l.
    • 2,001-2,500 m a.s.l.
    • 2,501-3,000 m a.s.l.
    • 3,001-4,000 m a.s.l.
    • > 4,000 m a.s.l.
    ......应用的技术
    • 凸形情况
    • 凹陷情况
    • 不相关
    土壤深度
    • 非常浅(0-20厘米)
    • 浅(21-50厘米)
    • 中等深度(51-80厘米)
    • 深(81-120厘米)
    • 非常深(> 120厘米)
    土壤质地(表土)
    • 粗粒/轻(砂质)
    • 中粒(壤土、粉土)
    • 细粒/重质(粘土)
    土壤质地(地表以下>20厘米)
    • 粗粒/轻(砂质)
    • 中粒(壤土、粉土)
    • 细粒/重质(粘土)
    表土有机质含量
    • 高(>3%)
    • 中(1-3%)
    • 低(<1%)
    地下水位
    • 表面上
    • < 5米
    • 5-50米
    • > 50米
    地表水的可用性
    • 过量
    • 中等
    • 匮乏/没有
    水质(未处理)
    • 良好饮用水
    • 不良饮用水(需要处理)
    • 仅供农业使用(灌溉)
    • 不可用
    水质请参考: 地下水和地表水
    盐度是个问题吗?

    洪水发生
    物种多样性
    • 中等
    栖息地多样性
    • 中等

    应用该技术的土地使用者的特征

    市场定位
    • 生计(自给)
    • 混合(生计/商业)
    • 商业/市场
    非农收入
    • 低于全部收入的10%
    • 收入的10-50%
    • > 收入的50%
    相对财富水平
    • 非常贫瘠
    • 贫瘠
    • 平均水平
    • 丰富
    • 非常丰富
    机械化水平
    • 手工作业
    • 畜力牵引
    • 机械化/电动
    定栖或游牧
    • 定栖的
    • 半游牧的
    • 游牧的
    个人或集体
    • 个人/家庭
    • 团体/社区
    • 合作社
    • 员工(公司、政府)
    性别
    • 女人
    • 男人
    年龄
    • 儿童
    • 青年人
    • 中年人
    • 老年人
    每户使用面积
    • < 0.5 公顷
    • 0.5-1 公顷
    • 1-2 公顷
    • 2-5公顷
    • 5-15公顷
    • 15-50公顷
    • 50-100公顷
    • 100-500公顷
    • 500-1,000公顷
    • 1,000-10,000公顷
    • > 10,000公顷
    规模
    • 小规模的
    • 中等规模的
    • 大规模的
    土地所有权
    • 公司
    • 社区/村庄
    • 团体
    • 个人,未命名
    • 个人,有命名
    土地使用权
    • 自由进入(无组织)
    • 社区(有组织)
    • 租赁
    • 个人
    • provisioning
    用水权
    • 自由进入(无组织)
    • 社区(有组织)
    • 租赁
    • 个人
    进入服务和基础设施的通道
    健康

    贫瘠
    x
    教育

    贫瘠
    x
    技术援助

    贫瘠
    x
    就业(例如非农)

    贫瘠
    x
    市场

    贫瘠
    x
    能源

    贫瘠
    x
    道路和交通

    贫瘠
    x
    饮用水和卫生设施

    贫瘠
    x
    金融服务

    贫瘠
    x

    影响

    社会经济影响
    作物生产
    降低
    x
    增加


    Improved soil health and diversity with reduces pest issues

    作物质量
    降低
    x
    增加


    Improved soil health and diversity with reduces pest issues

    饲料生产
    降低
    x
    增加


    Improved soil health and diversity with reduces pest issues

    饲料质量
    降低
    x
    增加


    Improved soil health and diversity with reduces pest issues

    畜牧生产
    降低
    x
    增加


    Better diversity of fodder available is producing healthier and better quality animals

    产品多样性
    降低
    x
    增加


    Sward mix in cover crop is very diverse

    饮用水的质量
    降低
    x
    增加


    Cover crops reduce soil wash-off and other water quality related impacts

    家畜用水的可用性
    降低
    x
    增加


    Cover crops reduce soil wash-off and other water related loss impacts

    家畜用水的质量
    降低
    x
    增加


    Cover crops reduce soil wash-off and other water quality related impacts

    农业收入
    降低
    x
    增加


    Improved crop and animal production

    工作量
    增加
    x
    降低


    Greater workload to rotationally graze and manage crop effectively in an organic system (i.e. can't rely on spraying to solve problems). Yet, benefits outweigh extra workload.

    社会文化影响
    SLM/土地退化知识
    减少
    x
    改良


    Vastly improved understanding through SLM expert advice and practical learning from doing SLM technology.

    生态影响
    水量
    降低
    x
    增加


    Cover crops help maintain soil moisture and reduce runoff through root system, improving water quantity held in field.

    水质
    降低
    x
    增加


    Cover crops reduce soil wash-off and other water quality related impacts

    地表径流
    增加
    x
    降低


    Cover crops reduce soil wash-off and other water quality related impacts

    蒸发
    增加
    x
    降低


    Cover crops help maintain soil moisture and reduce runoff through root system, improving water quantity held in field.

    土壤水分
    降低
    x
    增加


    Cover crops help maintain soil moisture and reduce runoff through root system, improving water quantity held in field.

    土壤覆盖层
    减少
    x
    改良


    Cover crops design is to cover soil and reduce soil loss

    土壤流失
    增加
    x
    降低


    Cover crops design is to cover soil and reduce soil loss

    土壤结壳/密封
    增加
    x
    减少


    Cover crops design is to cover soil and reduce soil crusting

    土壤压实
    增加
    x
    减少


    Reduced tillage techniques and less passes across fields with machinery as no spraying due to organic system reduces compaction.

    养分循环/补给
    降低
    x
    增加


    Selected species of cover crops help recharge nutrient availability in the soil

    土壤有机物/地下C
    降低
    x
    增加


    Cover crop rooting system & waste inversion as green manure increases the soil organic matter below ground.

    植被覆盖层
    降低
    x
    增加


    Cover crops design is to cover soil and reduce soil crusting

    生物量/地上C
    降低
    x
    增加


    Greater crop cover and thus more biomass above ground

    植物多样性
    降低
    x
    增加


    Well designed mixed cover crop seed mixes, although more expensive, provide a specialised plant diversity ideal for the farm system requirements.

    有益物种(捕食者、蚯蚓、传粉者)
    降低
    x
    增加


    Certain cover crops can attract beneficial species and help control pests and diseases

    栖息地多样性
    降低
    x
    增加


    A diverse vegetation supports greater habitat diversity

    害虫/疾病控制
    降低
    x
    增加


    Certain cover crops can attract beneficial species and help control pests and diseases

    洪水影响
    增加
    x
    降低


    Cover crops slow surface runoff and can hold a greater water capacity reducing flood risk and impact

    滑坡/泥石流
    增加
    x
    降低


    Cover crops slow surface run off and can hold a greater water capacity reducing potential for debris flows in storm events

    干旱影响
    增加
    x
    降低


    Cover crops slow surface runoff and can hold a greater water capacity reducing drought impacts

    场外影响
    下游洪水(不希望)
    增加
    x
    减少


    Cover crops slow surface runoff and can hold a greater water capacity reducing flood risk and impact

    地下水/河流污染
    增加
    x
    减少


    Cover crops slow surface runoff and can hold a greater water capacity reducing potential for debris flows and nutrient leaching downstream

    缓冲/过滤能力(按土壤、植被、湿地划分)
    减少
    x
    改良


    Cover crops slow surface runoff and can hold a greater water capacity reducing potential for debris flows and nutrient leaching downstream

    成本效益分析

    与技术建立成本相比的效益
    短期回报
    非常消极
    x
    非常积极

    长期回报
    非常消极
    x
    非常积极

    与技术维护成本相比的效益
    短期回报
    非常消极
    x
    非常积极

    长期回报
    非常消极
    x
    非常积极

    气候变化

    渐变气候
    年温度 增加

    非常不好
    非常好
    答案:未知
    年降雨量 增加

    非常不好
    非常好
    答案:未知
    气候有关的极端情况(灾害)
    局地雷暴

    非常不好
    非常好
    答案:未知
    局地雹灾

    非常不好
    非常好
    答案:未知

    采用和适应

    采用该技术的地区内土地使用者的百分比
    • 单例/实验
    • 1-10%
    • 11-50%
    • > 50%
    在所有采用这种技术的人当中,有多少人在没有获得物质奖励的情况下采用了这种技术?
    • 0-10%
    • 11-50%
    • 51-90%
    • 91-100%
    最近是否对该技术进行了修改以适应不断变化的条件?
    什么样的变化条件?
    • 气候变化/极端气候
    • 不断变化的市场
    • 劳动力可用性(例如,由于迁移)
    • Livestock feeding, economic interest, societal expectations
    Species are selected according to their ability to cover, feed and work the soil. To do this, species are chosen for their diversity and complementary according to their root system: tap roots, adventitious roots, surface lateral roots, etc. For the past 2 years, the Biomax green manure + RGA regrowth mix has been grazed by heifers.

    结论和吸取的教训

    长处: 土地使用者的观点
    • Sustain ecosystem health: no pest and disease problems, good herd health.
    • Carbon sequestration by enrichment of the soil with organic matter and by the work of earthworms favouring ecosystem functioning.
    • Protection of the soil and surface biodiversity because of maintained plant cover.
    • Increased weed control due to plant canopies and fertilisation effect of green manure.
    • Planted cover crops used as livestock feed during winter.
    • Sustained ecosystem integrity reduces/counters ecosystem degradation by using multiple ecosystem functions: Complementarity, Continuity of soil life, Green fertilizer essential in the farming system, Feeding the livestock.
    长处: 编制者或其他关键资源人员的观点
    • Multi-species cover is conducive to soil quality: production of a high above-ground and root biomass that promotes soil life, soil structuring at depth (tap roots) and on the surface (superficial roots) by the effect of organic matter inputs.
    • Multi-species cover provides shelter and cover for small fauna: seeds for the winter survival of the fauna, plants that are tiered at different heights without being too dense for wild game to move around while being protected.
    • The different families that can be planted under cover are:
      - Grasses are generally easy to grow and are valued by animals (oats, rye and sorghum).
      - Leguminous plants improve the performance of cover crops. They are regulating plants that trap nitrogen and fix it in the soil. This is then used by the crop that follows.
      - Cruciferous plants are to be reserved for cereal rotations without rapeseed or vegetables.
      - Compounds (nyger and sunflower) are interesting for biomass production.
    • Well-developed canopies have a competitive effect against weeds (germination inhibition, smothering, allelopathy). The aim is to have a rapidly developing canopy. It is necessary to limit the risks of shot blasting by sowing the canopy on clean soil, especially for early sowing (especially for short-cycle weeds: ragwort, bluegrass, Persian speedwell).

      Some species have allelopathic effects, i.e. they secrete inhibiting substances (the intensity of the allelopathic effect is taken from the Sem-Partners catalogue, see bibliography):
      - Diploid oats: allelopathic effect not demonstrated. Little is known about the mechanisms and molecules involved.
      - Spring Oats, Fenugreek, Gesse, Moha : average allelopathic effect, mechanisms and molecules involved are not well known.
      - Camelina, Radish: strong allelopathic effect (glucosinolates).
      - Winter mustard, Spring mustard: action of glucosinolates against nematodes (Heterodera Schaati and Meloidogyne chitwoodi) in biofumigation.
      - Buckwheat (Sarrazin): strong allelopathic effect. Little is known about the mechanisms and molecules involved.
    • A plant cover provides additional fodder, 3 to 4 tonnes of dry matter can be produced depending on the species and sowing date.
    弱点/缺点/风险: 土地使用者的观点如何克服
    • Difficulties in establishing cover: difficult lifting in dry areas Conditions for successful plant cover
      Sow as soon as possible
      Take advantage of the humidity just after harvest
    • Late sowing of cover crops: no or little flowering and therefore little beneficial effect Early establishment of complementary species
    • High cost of purchased seed of mixed protein cover crops Self-production of farm-saved seed
    弱点/缺点/风险: 编制者或其他关键资源人员的观点如何克服
    • In order to increase the potential of the canopies for bees, it is necessary to sow in the first half of August for flowering in the autumn. Some species are rich in nectar or pollen: rapeseed, white mustard, phacelia, radish, sunflower, clover, vetch. However, some species have extra-floral nectar such as sunflower, vetch and faba beans. That is to say that they secrete nectar outside the flowering period. Sow in the first half of August as soon as the cereals are harvested to take advantage of the residual moisture which is conducive to good emergence.
    • The development of RGA on the farm. Ploughing can slow down the development of RGA.
    • The cost of destroying the canopy is high (45€/ha excluding labour) with the 2 cross passes of rolling spade. 3) Cost of some tools for destroying the cover crops:
      Independent disc stubble cultivator 3m= 33€/ha
      Cultivator 3.5m = 20€/ha
      Mulcher 3m = 27 €/ha
      Cambridge roller 8m = 16€/ha
      Blade roller 3m = 17€/ha
      Assumptions: replacement value depreciated over 10 years + maintenance, tractor cost 20€/hour, labour not included
    • Before grazing a multi-species canopy, it is advisable to check the absence of toxic species (e.g. buckwheat) Not known
    • The doses and costs of implementing protein blend cutlery in interculture are high. - Adjusting Mixed Doses
      - Self-production of farm-saved seeds
      - Mixture with recommended doses
      (OBS: Do not exceed 120% pure dose)

    参考文献

    编制者
    • Alan Radbourne
    Editors
    • David Robinson
    • David Norris
    • Sabine Reinsch
    审查者
    • Rima Mekdaschi Studer
    • William Critchley
    实施日期: Feb. 17, 2020
    上次更新: Aug. 16, 2021
    资源人
    WOCAT数据库中的完整描述
    链接的SLM数据
    文件编制者
    机构 项目
    主要参考文献
    • Couvert végétal, une culture à part entière, Terra du 21 juin 2013: Terra (Réussir terragricoles de Bretagne) du 21 juin 2013
    • Couvert végétal, de réels avantages agronomiques, Terra 12 juin 2015: Terra 12 juin 2015
    • Couverts végétaux, la destruction possible dès le 1er février, Terra du 15 janvier 2016: Terra du 15 janvier 2016
    链接到网络上可用的相关信息
    This work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareaAlike 4.0 International